Exclusive: Dismissed GMP Sergeant Pursuing Multiple Legal Challenges After ICO Finds Force Breached Data Protection Law

A former Greater Manchester Police sergeant dismissed for gross misconduct is pursuing a series of legal challenges after the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) found the force failed to comply with its obligations under data protection law in its handling of evidence connected to her case.

Former Police Sergeant Natalie Dolan was dismissed without notice following a four-day misconduct hearing in April 2026 after a panel found she exchanged offensive WhatsApp messages with a student officer, mocked disabled people and trainee officers, disclosed confidential information and failed to properly manage a conflict of interest.

The misconduct panel concluded the combined breaches amounted to gross misconduct and Dolan was subsequently placed on the College of Policing’s Barred List.

Separate legal proceedings relating to the circumstances surrounding the investigation and dismissal remain ongoing.

In a decision issued on 14 November 2025, the Information Commissioner’s Office concluded that Greater Manchester Police “has not complied with its obligations under data protection law in this instance” regarding the handling of Dolan’s personal information.

The complaint centred on how WhatsApp messages containing evidence of possible misconduct were disclosed after being recovered during a criminal investigation.

The ICO found it was not satisfied Greater Manchester Police had demonstrated a lawful basis for escalating the messages to the detective leading the criminal investigation, rather than referring them directly to the Professional Standards Branch. The regulator stressed it was not finding that the misconduct concerns should not have been reported, only that it had not been shown the personal information had been disclosed through the appropriate route.

Although the ICO decided not to take formal regulatory action, it recommended that Greater Manchester Police review staff training and ensure officers and staff are clear on the correct procedure for escalating internal misconduct concerns.

Responding to Misconduct999, a Greater Manchester Police spokesperson said: “We have received and assessed the ICO’s report, following a review into the process regarding a misconduct investigation last year.

“The case resulted in the dismissal of an officer for discriminatory remarks, after it was found that the words used amounted to gross misconduct.

“Any findings shared with us are assessed, and we ensure that our processes are kept under continual review to ensure our robust standards are met.”

Following the publication of the ICO’s decision, Dolan told Misconduct999 that she continues to challenge matters arising from her dismissal through several ongoing legal proceedings.

She said she is awaiting a hearing before the Police Appeals Tribunal, is awaiting judgment in proceedings before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, and has two Employment Tribunal claims relating to alleged sex discrimination, disability discrimination, whistleblowing detriment, pay-related matters and victimisation. One of those claims is currently listed for hearing in April 2027.

Responding to Misconduct999, Dolan said the proceedings were “never about refusing to accept accountability” and accepted that police officers “should rightly be held to the highest professional standards”.

She said she believes there are “serious questions about the fairness and lawfulness of the way my case was investigated and progressed”, adding that her concern “has never simply been the outcome, but the process that led to it”.

Dolan said she wants “independent courts and tribunals to examine the evidence and determine whether the processes followed in my case were fair and lawful”, and that she does not believe the matter should be regarded as finally settled until those proceedings have concluded.

She also said she hopes the litigation will encourage “openness, fairness and accountability within the police misconduct system”, adding that she believes accountability “should never be one-sided” and that police forces should be prepared to answer concerns raised about the way misconduct investigations are conducted.

The ongoing proceedings are separate from both the ICO’s regulatory findings and the misconduct hearing that resulted in Dolan’s dismissal.

Greater Manchester Police
  • Stats since 1st January 2022
  • 147 Misconduct Hearings
    83% held in public

This archive brings together misconduct hearings, disciplinary outcomes and criminal cases involving officers from Greater Manchester Police. It includes reporting on hearings, published outcomes, and related court proceedings, along with indexed data on cases over time.

Receive Free Daily Police Misconduct Hearing Listings

Subscribe now

Hearings by Rank

PC: 2,169
(Rank undisclosed): 337
Sergeant: 250
Detective Constable: 159
Special Constable: 99
Detective Sergeant: 66
Inspector: 55
Detective Inspector: 21
Chief Inspector: 15
Former Officer: 15
Superintendent: 12
Chief Superintendent: 7
Special Sargeant: 6
Detective Chief Inspector: 5
Special Inspector: 4
Detective Superintendent: 3
Commissioner: 1
Chief Constable: 1
Chief Officer: 1
Deputy Assistant Commissioner: 1
Commander: 1
Special Superintendent: 1
Special Chief Inspector: 1
PCSO: 1

An investigative news agency that uncovers agenda-setting stories from across the UK