PC Brett Spruce Sacked Over Off-duty Nightclub Assault Reinstated After Appeal

Former PC Brett Spruce was dismissed by West Yorkshire Police after a panel found he had used unlawful force during an off-duty confrontation outside a nightclub. But a Police Appeals Tribunal has now overturned the gross misconduct findings and reinstated him to the force after ruling the original panel’s conclusions were ‘unreasonable’.

A former police officer who was sacked after punching a man outside a nightclub has won his appeal and is set to return to policing after a tribunal quashed findings of gross misconduct against him.

Former PC Brett Spruce, of West Yorkshire Police, had originally been dismissed without notice following a misconduct hearing in December 2024 over an incident which happened whilst he was off duty on 22 September 2023.

The original misconduct panel heard allegations that Spruce assaulted a man identified as AW outside a nightclub by pushing him and punching him in the face, causing him to lose consciousness.

He was also accused of refusing to provide his details to nightclub staff after the incident, leaving the scene while AW was on the floor, and later misleading his supervisor by claiming he acted in self-defence.

The panel, chaired by Assistant Chief Constable McCoubrey, found allegations relating to Discreditable Conduct and Honesty and Integrity proven. It concluded the officer’s actions amounted collectively to gross misconduct and dismissed him without notice.

But in a major reversal, a Police Appeals Tribunal chaired by Justine Davidge ruled the original findings concerning the assault and alleged dishonesty could not reasonably stand.

The tribunal heard that CCTV footage showed AW approached Spruce first and that there had been initial physical contact between the pair before the punch was thrown.

The original panel accepted that AW had initiated the interaction and may have pushed Spruce first, but nevertheless concluded the officer did not genuinely fear unlawful violence and that his response was disproportionate.

Spruce consistently maintained throughout the investigation and hearing that he acted in self-defence after being threatened by an intoxicated and aggressive man.

He told investigators that AW had become hostile because he believed Spruce had looked at or smiled at his girlfriend.

According to the officer’s account, AW verbally threatened him, approached aggressively and made physical contact before he responded with a push and then a single punch.

The tribunal found the original panel failed to properly analyse or explain why it rejected Spruce’s evidence about alleged verbal threats made by AW.

In its ruling, the tribunal stated the panel had ‘failed to assess properly the totality of the evidence before it’.

The appeal judges concluded the findings against Spruce over the assault allegation and the later allegation that he misled his supervisor were ‘outside of the range of reasonable findings’ open to the panel.

As a result, both findings were quashed.

However, the tribunal upheld a separate finding that Spruce committed misconduct by refusing to provide his details to security staff after the altercation.

The tribunal said it would have been ‘the right thing’ for a police officer to provide his details following a public altercation in which someone had been injured.

It ruled that misconduct alone warranted a Written Warning rather than dismissal.

Spruce was issued with an 18-month Written Warning and ordered to be reinstated.

The tribunal also confirmed that, for pay purposes, he would be treated as having served continuously since his dismissal, meaning he may be entitled to back pay, subject to deductions for other earnings during the period.

West Yorkshire Police
  • Stats since 1st January 2022
  • 118 Misconduct Hearings
    86% held in public

Receive Free Daily Police Misconduct Hearing Listings

Subscribe now

Hearings by Rank

PC: 2,174
(Rank undisclosed): 340
Sergeant: 251
Detective Constable: 159
Special Constable: 99
Detective Sergeant: 66
Inspector: 55
Detective Inspector: 21
Chief Inspector: 15
Former Officer: 15
Superintendent: 12
Chief Superintendent: 7
Special Sargeant: 6
Detective Chief Inspector: 5
Special Inspector: 4
Detective Superintendent: 3
Commissioner: 1
Chief Constable: 1
Chief Officer: 1
Deputy Assistant Commissioner: 1
Commander: 1
Special Superintendent: 1
Special Chief Inspector: 1
PCSO: 1

An investigative news agency that uncovers agenda-setting stories from across the UK